This commentary reflects the comments of Shiite as well as...

This commentary reflects the comments of Shiite as well as Sunni commentators (like Syed Qutb etc.) and is therefore a mixture of truth and falsehood. SURAH AL BAQARAH – VERSE 42 وََ Yْ%َ@ُ+ِا اَْf ِْ@َ\ِ)ِ وَYَ&ُُ0ْا اَْf وَأُ0ْ9َJْ Yَ َُ%ْنَ And do not mix up the truth with the falsehood, nor hide the truth while you know (it) 17 TAFSEER AL MIZAN – This is the commentary of Agha Muhammad Hussein Tabatabaie that is taught to higher level students.

This commentary of his is based on theological and philosophical considerations. Both of these are nothing but opinions, however an educated opinionated work it may be. BIHAR UL ANWAAR – CH 89 H 15 – TAFSEER AYYASHI ْ:َ َ=رِ ِ:ْ# “ُ)Bَ ْ:َ أ.ِ#َ َGِْ اِ ع َلَ BََْAُ ِ:َ اْMُLُ”(ِ-َ َلَ “ْ:َ َ4Lَ$َ َِ#أِِْ َ:َْ# اKْJِ:َْ َ/&َْ آَ*ََ وَ “ْ:َ َ6َ/ Iً-َ “ْ:ِ آِ َبِ اِ َ/&َْ آَ*ََ It has been narrated from Ammar Bin Musa who asked Abu Abdullahasws about the ordinances.

Heasws said: ‘Whoever gives a ruling between the two has disbelieved. Whoever interprets a Verse from the Book of Allahazwj has disbelieved.

BIHAR UL ANWAAR – CH 89 H 20 ِ:َ اJG.ِO ص َلَ “ْ:َ َلَ .ِ/ اْ&ُْIنِ ِ#Sَِْ ٍ$ِْ ََْ/ َGَ(أْ “َ&ُ0ََْ “َ:ِ اJرِ وَ َلَ ص “ْ:َ RَLَ$َ .ِ/ اْ&ُْIنِ َِ#أِِْ َ/َPَبَ َ/&َْ أْ2َTََ The Holy Prophetsaww said; ‘Whoever speaks from the Quran without knowledge let him take his place in the fire.’ And hesaww said: ‘Whoever speaks from the Quran by his opinion has erred.’ AL KAFI – H 549, Ch. 22, h1 ة “: أMP#J، : أ4= :# “M=، : اM:6 :# B، : اJ ا:# B(، : أ)ب :# اM و=ان :# ،.

: أ.# #W، : أ.# GاV ا6@م ل: M: ااDB(ن ./ ا$ و M: $ Rو A number of our people have narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Husayn ibn Sa‘id from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Ayyub ibn Hurr and ‘Imran ibn Ali from abu Basir from Abu ‘Abd Allah, recipient of divine supreme covenant, who has said the following: “We are the people well-established in knowledge and we are the ones who know how to interpret it.” AL KAFI – H 184, Ch. 20, h6 c >c% ا c ،,cA8 ،ن- I@% A ،ل^.

ا ، 8أ ، إQ $% أ $ \7 ,-% ا+Mم واQ*I k -%JG ا+Mم Muhammad ibn Yahya has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from ibn Mahbub from ‘Amr ibn abu al-Miqdam from Jabir who has said that he heard abu Ja‘far, 19 recipient of divine supreme covenant, say the following: “No one from the people has claimed to have collected the whole of the Holy Quran as it was revealed. If anyone comes up with such a claim, he is a liar.