ভূমিকা

{"id":27108,"date":"2024-08-04T18:00:44","date_gmt":"2024-08-04T18:00:44","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/hubeali.com\/?p=27108"},"modified":"2024-08-04T18:12:12","modified_gmt":"2024-08-04T18:12:12","slug":"defence-of-12-imami-shias-against-bohra-allegations","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/hubeali.com\/defence-of-12-imami-shias-against-bohra-allegations\/","title":{"rendered":"Defence of 12 Imami Shias against Bohra Allegations"},"content":{"rendered":" Defence of 12 Imami Shias against Bohra Allegations \n A short document against the 12 Imami Shia (Asna e Ashari) has been circulated, as written by a Bohri scholar \u2013 its text without editing is reproduced in Appendix I.

Below, we answer to each of the four allegations raised against the beliefs of 12 Imami Shias. \n Bohra scholar allegation: 1 \n (Referring to a Hadith of Rasool Allah -saww , the first allegation is:) \n \u201c\u2019Hazrat Imam Hassan (A.S.) and Hazrat Imam Hussain (A.S.) are the chief of all youths in paradise and their father (Hazrat Ali Maula-e-Kaenat A.S.) is better than both of them.\u2019 – So Ithna Asharee Firqa can not include Hazrat Ali (A.S.) in the list of 12 Imams, as his (A.S.) position is better than that of an Imam (A.S.).

\n \u201cIn other words, Hazrat Ali (A.S.) is the \u2018Managing Director\u2019 and can not be included in the list of Imams (A.S.). His position can not be be lowered, to complete the 12 Imams.

Therefore, if we exclude Hazrat Ali (A.S.) from the list of 12 Imams, the total is only 11 Imams.\u201d \n Defence of 12 Imami Shias against allegation: 1 \n This is very strange logic \u2013 Prophet Mohammed -saww is better than the previous Prophets -as , so will our Bohra brother exclude Prophet Mohammed -saww from the list of Prophets -as too?

\n There are so many Ahadith, however for the sake of brevitiy in this article, we present three Ahadith below: in the first Hadith, the Prophet -saww says he -saww is the chief of the Prophets -as and Ali -asws is the chief of the Waseen (Imams); in the second Hadith, the Prophet -saww says their (Imam Hassan -asws \u2018s and Imam Hussain -asws \u2019s) father (Imam Ali -asws ) is better than them -asws and counts Ali -asws Ibn Abi Talib -asws in the list of twelve Imams -asws ; and in the third Hadith, the Prophet gives the names of the twelve Imams -asws after him -saww .