\n In the later part of the Hadith from Rijal Al-Kashi...

\n In the later part of the Hadith from Rijal Al-Kashi, he returns to the topic and says, Imam Jafar-e-Sadiq \u2011asws denounces a Ghali and says, I -asws have not asked them to delay Salat of Maghrib until stars becomes visible.\u00a0 We do not find any issue with the quoted Hadith, as this Hadith is consistent with other Ahadith, i.e., Imam-e-Zaman -ajfj says (in a Touqi Mubarak): (Imam -ajfj says) He is maloun who delays his Salat of Maghrib until the appearance of the stars, Hadith is given in Appendix II.

\n At 48:00 minutes , the reformist alleges that Imam Sadiq -asws did not know the names of all stars in the sky (Nouzobillah), but in the Hadith, Imam -asws meant that there is no such star as named by Abu Khatab in the sky.

\n At 49:50 minutes , the reformist wishes if Shias were to merge with the rest of the Ummah, like him; \n At 56:00 minutes , the reformist alleges while presenting a second Hadith from Rijal Al-Kashi, that if someone waits 20 minutes after sunset, he would miss the time of Maghrib; \n Our reply: From scientific observations, depending where one is with reference to the equator, for naked eye sky observations, it takes from 40 to 140 minutes after sunset, the visibility of the stars as darkness starts to prevail.

In Lahore (Pakistan) Shias offer Maghrib Salat (Break Fast after Salat) 8-10 minutes after Sunset. For example, in London (UK) today (15\/05\/23) Sunset was at 20:47, Maghrib time was 21:06, the stars have not appeared still at 21:38 (so over 50 minutes after the sunset stars have not become visible as there is still light in the sky). Stars start to appear at about 21:52 (~ an hour after sunset).

A very similar observation in London was made on next day (sunset 20:47, Maghrib 21:06, end of Maghrib Salat 21:18 and enough still light, at 21:47 no stars until 22:00). \n At 1:03 , the reformist contradicts the Usooli Rejal Ahadith criteria by saying even if a Hadith comes from Imam Jafar e Sadiq -asws , which has sound and reliable narrators regarding delaying a few minutes Maghrib Salat after sunset, he would reject it!