Once the 2 nd caliph (Umar) passed derogatory comments after...

Once the 2 nd caliph (Umar) passed derogatory comments after kissing (istalam) of Black Stone, and Mola Ali –asws rebuked him, see the Hadith: عن الحلبي، قال: سألته: لم جعل استلام الحجر؟ قال: «إن الله حيث أخذ الميثاق من بني آدم دعا الحجر من الجنة و أمره و التقم الميثاق، فهو يشهد لمن وافاه بالموافاة».

From Al Halby who said, ‘I asked him -asws , ‘Why has the kissing been Made to be for the (Black) Stone?’ He -asws said: ‘Allah -azwj , when He -azwj Took the Covenant from the Children of Adam -as , called the (Black) Stone from the Paradise and Commanded it, and it devoured the Covenant. Thus, it would be testifying for the one who was loyal to it with the fulfilment’’.

[10] و عن عبيد الله الحلبي، عن أبي جعفر، و أبي عبد الله (عليهما السلام) قالا: «حج عمر أول سنة حج و هو خليفة، فحج تلك السنة المهاجرون و الأنصار، و كان علي (عليه السلام) قد حج في تلك السنة بالحسن و الحسين (عليهما السلام) و بعبد الله بن جعفر- And from Ubeydullah Al Halby, (It has been narrated) from Abu Ja’far -asws and Abu Abdullah -asws both having said: ‘Umar went for Hajj in the first year he was the caliph, and the emigrants and the Helpers (also) went to Hajj in that year, and it so happened that Ali -asws performed Hajj in that year with Al-Hassan -asws and Al-Husayn -asws and with Abdullah -asws Bin Ja’far -asws .

قال-: فلما أحرم عبد الله لبس إزارا و رداء ممشقين- مصبوغين بطين المشق- ثم أتى فنظر إليه عمر، و هو يلبي و عليه الإزار و الرداء، و هو يسير إلى جنب علي (عليه السلام)، فقال عمر من خلفهم: ما هذه البدعة التي في الحرم، فالتفت إليه علي (عليه السلام)، فقال له: يا عمر، لا ينبغي لأحد أن يعلمنا السنة، فقال عمر: صدقت- يا أبا الحسن- لا و الله، ما علمت أنكم هم». He (the narrator) said, ‘So when Abdullah -asws wore Ihram, he wore a trouser and a cloak both dyed in red ochre (natural earth pigment).

Umar looked at him, and he was exclaiming Tailbiyya, and upon him was the trouser and the cloak, and he was walking to the side of Ali -asws . Umar said from behind them -asws . ‘What is this innovation which is in the Harrum?’ So Ali -asws turned towards him and said to him: ‘O Umar! It is not befitting for anyone that he teaches us -asws the Sunnah’. Umar said, ‘You -asws speak the truth, O Abu Al-Hassan -asws ! No, by Allah -azwj , I did not know (who) you -asws were’.