\n \n Seyyid Mahdi Marashi ...

\n \n Seyyid Mahdi Marashi : \n \n Whoever says these things and is insistent on what he says…he is “Dal” and “Modal”, \n (a person who is himself deviant and who also deviates others), and one cannot rely on what he believes and writes, because his books are “books of aberration” ; and it is not permitted to publish them. It is mandatory for scholars…to stand against such persons and to warn people about them. \n Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf \/ al-Mashedi, pg 392.

\n \n Shaykh Basher-Hosayn Najafi : \n \n These statements which are contradictory to the Ja’fari (Shiah) sect, and are “Dal” and “Modal” (deviant and deviating) …have not come from other than a soul which has been blinded by Nosb ( hatred of Ahl-al-bayt), which deprived it of its ability to understand the religion, and a soul whose senses were overcome and captivated by the love for this world.

May Allah protect the Moslems from these vile statements, and the evil of their originator, the carrier of Nosb and hatred for the Masom Aemmah. \n Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf \/ al-Mashedi, pg 432. \n \n Shaykh Hosayn Nori Hamadani : \n \n I am doubtful about his Ijthehad, therefore from now on I will not support him; and I do not permit (others) to help and support him in propagating his thoughts.

\n Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf \/ al-Mashedi, pg 435 \n I have also repeatedly suggested to his supporters in Qom that he travels to Mashhad or Qom for the Ziyarah of Imam Reda and Fatimah Mas’omah, and he meets with the scholars and answers their questions and objections; but unfortunately he has not done so.

\n Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf \/ al-Mashedi, pg 439 \n \n Sayyed Taqi Qommi : \n \n Whoever says these things about the likes of Zahra, he has opposed the correct belief and this person, according to the She’ah view, is a denier of a “Darori” (a belief in which a person must believe inorder to be classified as a believer, like the Holy Quran is the word of Allah is a Darori) and the denier of a Darori could be counted as an athiest.

\n Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf \/ al-Mashedi, pg 380. \n \n Late Sayyed Mohammed Sadr : \n \n This book (al-Masael al-Fehiyyah\/Fadlollah) is a “book of aberration”, and shows that its author is not a mujtahid. \n Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf \/ al-Mashedi, pg 423.