ভূমিকা

Refuting the breaking of Fast with Aamma (General Muslims) | Hubeali Skip to content Hubeali Menu Topics Quran Tafseer Books Urdu Books English Books Sermons School of Wilayat Search for: Search Button Home Articles Refuting the breaking of Fast with Aamma (General Muslims) Details Sidebar Table of contents Summary: Our rebuttal to the reformist of the video (https://youtu.be/1eS8TXBq-7I): One has to repeat Fast if opened earlier than Al-Layl: Explanation of the Disc falls (Sunset) in Ahadith: Further Clarity on Fast Breaking time: When is the Sunset (observed)?

Nothing Happens to the Fast by delaying it by a few minutes: The Definition of Al-Layl in the Holy Quran: There is Vastness in the Religion: Concluding Remarks: APPENDIX I: Replies to some of the main points of the reformist Allegations of the reformer and our defence: APPENDIX II: Don’t Delay Maghrib until appearance of the stars at night Refuting the breaking of Fast with Aamma (General Muslims) Download PDF (Refuting to the video link below) https://youtu.be/1eS8TXBq-7I Summary: During the month of Ramazan this year (2023), the above video link was sent to us, where the speaker (the so called reformist) is seen to be trying very hard to make an issue of a non-issue which has been settled for centuries – that the slight delay in breaking Fast by the twelve Imami Shias is wrong and they should rather be embracing the practice of the Aamma (general Muslims) and break their fast and offer Maghrib Salat at the same time as the Sunnis and Salafis do – for the sake of demonstrating solidarity and unity with their Muslim brethren.

Ironically, the unity would be short lived as the reformist(s) won’t be joining them in the Tarawiaya Salat to follow: The reformist in the above video link ( https://youtu.be/1eS8TXBq-7I ), ignores the Holy Quran, and then ignores the criteria of establishing the authenticity of Ahadith – as well recognised by the all-Muslim sects (i.e., to compare a Hadith with the Holy Quran) but rather focuses only on the man-made and Sunni Imam fabricated criteria of ilmul rijal (knowledge about the character of the narrators).

The real purpose of creating a storm in a teacup, apparently to create divisions and discontentment among the Shia community, as all twelve Imami followers (i.e., Usoolis and Akhbari) unanimously agree that the fast-breaking time of general Muslims is earlier than what Quran and Ahadith commend us (i.e., Verse 2:187 observe Fast to the Layl).