(3) On the other hand...

(3) On the other hand, if he preaches, he again has disobeyed God where Allah states “O you who believe! why do you say that which you do not act? It is most hateful in the sight of Allah that you say that which you do not act.!!!” Didn’t Almighty Allah reprimand the Jews by saying: “Do you enjoin right conduct on the people, and forget (to practice it) yourselves, and yet you study the Scripture?

Will you not understand?” (4) Clearly, a Prophet cannot order a layman to perform prayer on a timely basis, when the Prophet himself forgets to pray, and when he remembers, he prays without ablution (Wudu)!!! (5) Purified be the Representatives of Almighty Allah from such false accusations! Third, a Prophet that sins are a repulsive character. We, as humans, detest a person who comes to us and says don’t do this and don’t do that, yet he himself commits wicked acts.

He automatically becomes repulsive to us, and we cannot stand to listen to him anymore. Similarly, if (PBUHH) was cruel to a blind man, which he was not, how can he ask us to have good manners? (NOTE AGAIN: The blind man’s story is not related to the Prophet (PBUHH) as some Sunnis state; it was a chapter revealed to reprimand Uthman ibn Affan, who was the one who frowned in the face of the blind man. Please see the earlier article which was exclusively in this regard).

Do you seriously believe that a Prophet of Almighty Allah was a sinner and so offensive? Why do you follow him then? I, personally, will not believe in a man who claims to be sent by Almighty Allah, the Creator of the Universe, and then sins and behaves in a manner that is not even befitting of a beast! Forth, was Almighty Allah so incapable as to make His (SWT) Prophets and Messengers sinless? Why would Almighty Allah even bother to send a sinning Prophet to be an example to a community?

If sin is something that even the Prophets and Messengers cannot avoid, then what is the purpose of sending a religion to mankind anyway? Does God expect ordinary people to follow his instructions when his own deputies cannot? Fifth, a Prophet or Messenger is an interpreter of Allah’s commands. As such, if the prophet is the first to violate these commands, who among the Ummah will abide by these commands?

Or if he is in a state that deprives him of his mental faculties causing him to err, then he will misinterpret the commands of Almighty Allah. If that happens, then surely Almighty Allah is playing a game with His creation!