All he did were in full accordance with Allah’s wishes and commandments.

All he did were in full accordance with Allah’s wishes and commandments. But religion is not limited to what is obligatory and what is forbidden. Most of the Prophet’s actions fall in the category of what is “Mustahabb” (i.e., recommended) or what is “Mubaah” (i.e., OK either way). Moreover, no one said we are required to imitate all the actions of the Prophet.

If one eats what the Prophet preferred to eat, it will be all right and no one can blame him unless he claims that one should eat only what the Prophet ate. Obeying the Prophet (PBUHH) means that if the Prophet orders to do something or forbade to do something, then one is religiously required…