ভূমিকা

Death of the Prophet: Sunni and Shia Perspectives The Scientific and Cultural Website of Shia belief Death of the Prophet: Sunni and Shia Perspectives 2025-08-21 370 Views The death of the (PBUHH) marks one of the most pivotal and sensitive moments in Islamic history. Beyond the profound emotional impact, the death of the Prophet also triggered significant developments in the political, theological, and social structures of the nascent Muslim community.

This event not only closed the chapter of divine revelation but also opened a new phase in the life of the ummah, raising critical questions about leadership, authority, and continuity.

Contents Historical Context Leading to the Death of the Prophet The Event of the Prophet’s Death Immediate Aftermath of the Death The Question of Succession Among Muslims, both Sunni and Shia traditions hold deep reverence for the (PBUHH), yet their historical accounts and interpretations of the death of the Prophet (PBUHH) differ in key aspects.

These differences are not limited to the moment of his passing, but extend to the surrounding circumstances—such as the final illness, the presence or absence of certain individuals, and the events that followed immediately after. The purpose of this study is to examine the death of the Prophet (PBUHH) from both Sunni and Shia historical perspectives.

By comparing the narratives recorded in their respective traditions, this paper aims to highlight not only the areas of convergence but also the underlying reasons for divergence. Through this comparative lens, the death of the Prophet becomes a window into understanding broader theological and sectarian developments in Islamic history.

Historical Context Leading to the Death of the Prophet The death of the (PBUHH) did not occur in isolation but was preceded by a series of significant events that shaped the political and emotional landscape of the Muslim community. Both Sunni and Shia sources emphasize the importance of the Prophet’s final days, marked by illness, critical instructions, and interactions with key figures that would later become focal points of theological and historical contention.

The Prophet’s illness began shortly after his return from the Farewell Pilgrimage (Ḥajj al-Wadāʿ) in 11 AH / 632 CE [1] .