Needless to say that I found later on that the above...
Needless to say that I found later on that the above attitude has no confirmation in the Quran nor in the lifestyle of the Prophet of Islam and his twelve successors. They have always been addressing all questions in the best manner without condemning or labeling the questioners with heresy or innovation. 2. Denial The second attitude is to deny the existence of God as Russell and many others perhaps do when they fail to find any answer for the question.
As a matter of fact, the first and the second group have a similar problem in that they have both failed to find any answer for the question. The difference however between them is that the first group have just censored their minds and convinced themselves that they should have just faith in it. You tell them how can you prove it. They tell you we can't for it is beyond logic! And then you are speechless. 3.
Answer I believe the above question is one of the very basic questions about the existence of God and if this does not have any answer, then no religious issue shall be analysed logically. The Fallacy of the Question As a matter of fact, there is a fallacy in the question as presented by Russell. It is very disappointing to see a thinker such as Russell misinterpret the argument of the First Cause and assumes that the Creator of the world is part of the world, even though the first part!
I may however justify the fallacy of Russell's argument by the misrepresentation of many Christian theologians from whom Russell is quoting. The concept of God for a typical Christian from childhood is a humane concept. The Old Testament teaches that God has created man of His own image and the central doctrine of Christianity, which suggest that Jesus Christ is incarnate son of God and is believed to be embodiment of God in human form.
Such wrong concepts of God are, I believe, one of the major reasons for declination of religion in the West and the prevalence of atheism. Let us remember that Russell's title of lecture was ‘Why I Am Not a Christian', not why he does not believe in God. Every possible being needs a cause All what we perceive in this world enjoy inevitably the following characteristics. Limitation: all the objects around us from a tiny atom to the giant galaxies have occupied a limited space.
They may wary in size and volume but they are all in common is the fact that they all have a limit. In other words they all belong to a specific time and place.