Abu Bakr said: Abd-arrahman did not like this.

Abu Bakr said: Abd-arrahman did not like this. Then it happened that we gathered in Dhi-Hulaifah where Abu Hurairah had a piece of earth. Abd-arrahman told Abu Hurairah: I am telling you this, and if Marwan did not ask me (by swear) for this, I would not have been mentioning this to you. Then he mentioned the (traditions) narrated by Aisha and Umm Salamh. He (Abu Hurairah) said: al-fadhl Ibn Abbas narrated me so and he is more knowledgeable.

Hammam and Ibn Abdullah Ibn Umar narrated from Abu Hurairah that the prophet ordered for opening the sawm (and not to fast), (obviously) the first chain (from Aisha and Umm Salam) is more trustable. The above traditions are taken from: The translation of the meaning of Sahih al-Bukhari Arabic-English Dr. Mohammad Muhsin Khan Islamic University, Medina al-Munawwara Kaze Publications. In article elrabaa@sun14.vlsi.uwaterloo.ca (M.

ElRabaa) writes: Again Kamran is spelling his misconceptions into the net ... Abu-Hurirah (RA) stayed very close to the Prophet (alihi assalato wassalam) for few years, he did not go to markets Dear Brother Mohammad, I would like to ask you the following question: Do you know for how long Abu-Hurirah Has stayed with the Prophet? The answer is found in the following sunni referances: al-Milala wa al-Nihal, by iben al-Jawzia, Pub. Egypt. Sirat iben Hisham, Pub. Egypt.

Abu-Hurirah became a moslem only two years before the Prophet (s.a.w) died. Therefore, How can he report some 2000 hadith in the Saheeh al-Bukhari alone, while there are olny very few hadiths are reported by Imam Ali, Imam Al-Hasan,Imam al-Husain, or Fatimah al-zahrah. How would you explain such things ? I am intrested in your objective and scientific answer supported by some referances. Prophet (alihi assalato wassalam) almost 24 hrs a day !!! That is why he narrated a lot of ahadith ...

He also narrated a lot of ahadith which he heard from other sahaba (RAA) ... sahaba were good muslims and trusted each other, so he took some ahadith from the sahaba ... As for the example of contradiction Kamran gives, all I can say is this, go and check a fiqh book !!! I mentioned this before several times ... to make a ruling of ahadith, you have to check fiqh books ... it is not a straight forword matter ...

if someone is interested and does not have a fiqh book (like Fiqh El-sunnah) pls Dear brother, I have The above mentioned book, Fiqh al-sunnah, by Said Sabiq, Published in Egypt.