He says: “The claim of Uthman bin Saeed a deputy of Imam Hasan (a.

He says: “The claim of Uthman bin Saeed a deputy of Imam Hasan (a.s), that His Eminence had a [1] Sabaikuz Zahab, Pg. 78 [2] At Tashiyyo wash-Shia, Pg.

31 son who will not appear to anyone and he is the Awaited Imam and the Mahdaviyat is firm with him, and from all aspects all his claims and statements are baseless.” However, his statement is absolutely invalid because we have already quoted in the forgone discussions, in a clear manner, traditions and reports from the Holy Prophet (a.s) and Purified Imams (a.s) and all those narrations and reports have given glad tidings to the world of Islam about the reappearance of Imam Mahdi (a.s) and that His Eminence will revive the religion and make it strong.

Ahmad Amin Ahmad Amin, like the Magian Kasravi is also having malice and jealously against Imams of guidance, whom the Almighty Allah has purified from all filth and impurities. He also issued statements on the basis of his bigotry, instead of referring to authentic Shia sources. He made baseless claims and false allegations regarding them and he has himself accepted this. Due to his animosity towards the Shias he has heaped every type of falsehood on them.

Those Shias who shape a great part of the Islamic community and desire truth and justice and despise dispute, rebellion and oppression are well known. Dr.

Abdur Rahman Badawi says, “Shias posses greater virtue and are pre-eminent among all because they have preserved Islam with its originality and perfection and bestowed the restless and confused consciences with spirituality, steadfastness and aplomb; otherwise petrifaction and a dry and motionless structure would become dominant.” In any case, Ahmad Amin has written a treatise in which he has denied Imam Mahdi (a.s) and considered the Shia belief regarding His Eminence a defect.

He has not given any importance to the traditions of the six canonical books of Ahle Sunnat on the subject. The compilers of books of Prophetic narrations, the widely related reports and widespread sayings of the Prophet of Islam (a.s) regarding Imam Mahdi (a.s) are known to all. The great scholar, Hujjatul Islam wal Muslimeen Ustad Shaykh Muhammad Ali Zahiri have refuted Ahmad Amin with logical arguments and textual proofs. He has replied to the baseless statements of Ahmad Amin.