And they always repeat saying: “Good is whatever Allah wills.

And they always repeat saying: “Good is whatever Allah wills.” SECOND: They argue saying that had Ali become the caliph immediately after the Prophet and was followed by al-Hasan and al-Husayn, the caliphate would have turned hereditary, with sons inheriting their fathers, something the religion of Islam, which gave people the right of shura , does not sanction.

In order to respond and to remove the confusion, we would like to state the following: FIRST: There is not a single proof that what happened was something desired and chosen by Allah; rather, arguments to the contrary are fixed in the Holy Qur'an and the Sunnah. The Qur'an, for example says, “Had the people of the towns believed and feared (their Lord), We would have opened unto them blessings from the heavens and…