He would be resurrected as a ____________ 1 Muslim's Sahih vol.

He would be resurrected as a ____________ 1 Muslim's Sahih vol. p.48-49. 2 As-Seera an-Nabawiyya, vol.1 p.96. nation by himself." (1) It was mentioned too that the Prophet (s) had said: "May Allah have mercy upon Qass bin Sa'ida. He would be resurrected in the Day or Resurrection as one nation or as a nation by himself." (2) So what was this contradiction?

Why was the Prophet (s) so generous to the non-relatives, who had never done him any favor, and was so miser towards his uncle, who had done him great favors since his childhood until he became a prophet? Hadn't his Lord revealed to him: (Is the reward of goodness aught but goodness?) 55:60. Then why would the Prophet (s) reward his uncle with else than goodness?

After all we found that accusing Abu Talib of being unbeliever would harm the Prophet (s) and this would be a great sin that could never be forgiven. Allah the Almighty said: (... and (as far) those who molest the Messenger of Allah, they shall have a painful punishment) 9:61. (... and it does not behave you that you should give trouble to the Messenger of Allah) 33:53.

(Surely (as far) those who speak evil things of Allah and His Messenger, Allah has cursed them in this world and the hereafter, and He had prepared for them a chastisement bringing disgrace) 33:57. Hence we found that at-Talmassani had said that the one, who accused Abu Talib of being unbeliever, should be killed because it would harm the Prophet (s) and whoever harmed the Prophet (s) should be killed. The Muslims agreed upon killing the one, who ____________ 1 Ala Hamish as-Seera vol.

p.136, As-Seera an-Nabawiyya, vol.1 p.73, 76, 95. 2 Biharul Anwar, vol.6 p.57, As-Seera an-Nabawiyya, vol.1 p.73, 76, Murooj ath-Thahab vol.1 p.69-70. harmed the Prophet (s), according to the Quranic verses, which confirmed that whoever harmed the Prophet (s) would be in Hell for ever. No harm was be caused to the Prophet (s) more than defaming his uncle and supporter and accusing him of being unbeliever whereas he was a sincere believer and a nonesuch supporter.

They mentioned that one day Subay'a bint Abu Lahab had come to the Prophet (s) complaining that people often said to her: "You are the daughter of the firewood of Hell (for she was the daughter of Abu Lahab)." The Prophet (s) stood up angrily and said: "Why do some people harm me with my relatives?