ভূমিকা

Shiavault - a Vault of Shia Islamic Books The Conception of the Sahaba's Ultimate Decency and the Political Authority in Islam Chapter 10 — Objective Analysis, and Denial of Serendipity Among Sunnis' historians, there is a sort of unanimity on the fact that it was Omar who first knew of the Ansar’s meeting.[178] According to another narrative, it was Abu­Bakr who informed him of this news.[179] A third narrative related by bn­Husham, however, tells that a man came to Omar and Abu­Bakr and told of the news.[180] No single historian could realize the name of that man who carried the news to Abu­Bakr and Omar!!

The loss of this man's name should have never be an accidental matter. It seems that he was one of the celebrities in that society since he had acquaintance of secret matters of such a degree of sensitivity. Then, how should Abu­Bakr and Omar have listened and believed him if he had not been a noble character? The name of such a noble individual that carried such an important news, should have never been lost.

This matters throws shades of suspicion whether this man had been actually existed or had he been a mere legend!! As a matter of fact, it cannot be an accidental matter that Omar would be the only individual who had been fully acquainted of the meeting held secretly by the Ansar, the majority of the Prophet's capital. What was the reason beyond Omar's having called Abu­Bakr lonelily for informing of this news?

Why did he not call the entire Muhajirs who were taking the final look at their prophet and Imam, and participating the honorable household in their disastrous misadventure? This matter should not be considered as an accidental event. Moreover, at which location was Al­Faruq who lost his physical capability as soon as he had been informed of the Prophet's decease, and menaced to kill and amputate the limbs of those who claimed of the Prophet's decease?

Normally, he should have gone to the Prophet's house when he was convinced of the his decease, for taking the final look and participating in people's misfortune? Supposing he did direct towards the Prophet's house, how could he exclusively realize the news of the [178] At­Tabari's book of history part.3 page 219. [179] At­Tabari's book of history part.3 page 201. [180] bn­Husham's book of history part.2 pagte 656. Ansar’s meeting? Who carried this news to him particularly?

How should that carrier of news have found Omar among thousands of people crowding there?