630) Document No.

630.Document No. 11 “And Ali and Bani Hashim refused to give Bay’at… then came to them Umar and took them to give Bay’at.” [4] Ibne Abil Hadeed (d. 656) narrates from Abu Bakr Jauhari (d. 323) Document No. 12 “Then Umar entered and said to Ali: Get up and do Bay’at. But he did not pay attention and did not come out from the house. Umar held him by his hand and again said: Get up. Ali again refused to get up. Umar held him by force and threw him. In the same way, he behaved with Zubair too.