ভূমিকা

Shiavault - a Vault of Shia Islamic Books Completion of Argument The Thorn and the flower (Objections against Shia faith published in the ‘Rizwan’ Magazine, Lahore. Sayyadush Shohada[^1] Special Issue 1374 A.H.) Objection 1: Forged Quran Again this year read about some interesting beliefs and laws of the Shia faith and gain lesson from them.

Muslims all over the world believe that the Quran in our hands is the one revealed by Allah and that it is exactly as it was revealed upon the Messenger of Allah (S). However the Shia belief is exactly opposite; that the existing Quran is a fabricated one. It has been distorted while the real Quran is with the Hidden Imam who is hiding in a cave. He will come with the real Quran sometime before the Day of Judgment. All right sir! So this is a forged Quran.

But how sensible is this Hidden Imam that he has hidden the real Quran and does not guide the creatures of God!

It is narrated on page 271 of Usul al-Kafi that Imam Ja’far as-Sadiq (as) said, “The Quran that Jibraeel (as) brought to the Messenger of Allah (S) had seventeen thousand verses.” On the same page of this book another tradition is narrated that Imam Ja’far as-Sadiq (as) brought out the Quran inscribed by Imam Ali (as) and said, “By Allah, after this day you will never see the Quran.” On page 146 of the same book another tradition says that Imam Ja’far as-Sadiq (as) remarked, “We have a ‘Jame’ (collection).

It is seventy yards long.” It means that according to the Shia school of thought no one will see the real Quran till the reappearance of Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.). The real Quran is seventy yards long and has seventeen thousand verses. As if a ladder would be needed to read it. Objection 2: Mus’haf-e-Fatima The famous religious book of Shias, Usul al-Kafi has the following tradition on page 146: Imam (as) said, “We have Mus’haf-e-Fatima.

And do you know what is Mus’haf-e-Fatima?” He said, “It is a Quran, and by Allah! It does not have even a single letter in common with your Quran.” Now, this is a third Quran. First a forged one, then a real one, which is with the Hidden Imam and a Mus’haf-e-Fatima also. But we don’t know in which cave it is and who is hiding with Mus’haf-e-Fatima. Objection 3: Bada (Change in Divine Will) The principle of Bada in Shia ideology is also very strange. They say that Bada happens to God.