Can a religion be called a religion where one gets honor in...

Can a religion be called a religion where one gets honor in concealing it and disgrace in revealing it? Objection 6: Who killed the Imam? Shias blame Amir Muawiyah for the assassination of Imam (as). Some Shias even say that the Imam was assassinated only on the order of Muawiyah. However, Shia scholars have themselves concocted these allegations. Reliable Shia books prove that Amir Muawiyah had nothing to do in the Imam’s murder.

📌Mulla Baqir Majlisi writes in Jalalul Uyun [^2] that Amir Muawiyah willed to Yazid at the time of his death: “But as for Imam Husain (as)! You know his relation and nearness to the Holy Prophet (S). He is a part of the Prophet. I know that the people of Iraq will call him and would not help him. If you get control over him, recognize his rights. Remember his rank of nearness to the Prophet.

Do not make him recompense for his actions and do not break off the relations I have strengthened with him during this time. Beware! Do not give him any kind of trouble. It is narrated in Nasikhut Tawarikh that Muawiyah made the following will to Yazid: O son! Do not be greedy. Beware, when you come to Allah you should not have the blood of Husain bin Ali upon your neck. Otherwise, you will not be at ease and remain under chastisement forever. This narration is also from the book of Shias.

At least it proves that Muawiyah was not involved in the martyrdom of Husain (as). He had willed Yazid to respect and help the Imam. Then we do not understand why Amir Muawiyah is blamed for the martyrdom of the Imam? Objection 7: Shias and Imam Mahdi It is narrated in Usul al-Kafi : “If the number of Shias come to three hundred and thirteen, Imam Mahdi (a.t.f.s.) will reappear.”[^3] Did you understand anything? The book of Shias is opposing themselves.

It says that if at anytime and anywhere the number of true Shias comes to three hundred and thirteen, Imam Mahdi will reappear. But the Imam is not ready to leave the cave. It proves that all these Shias seen everywhere in large numbers are not true believers but enemies of Ahlul Bayt. If at anytime the number of Shias had come to three hundred and thirteen, the Imam would have surely reappeared. Since the Imam has not reappeared the conclusion is clear.

✦ ✦ ✦