Al-Bukhari said, “ Whatever he narrated from his book is MORE sahih .

Al-Bukhari said, “ Whatever he narrated from his book is MORE sahih .” Al-Daraqutni said, “ Thiqah (trustworthy), but he made mistakes in ahadith from Ma’mar.” Ibn Hibban said, “He used to make mistakes when he narrated from his memory, plus (there was) Shi’ism in him.” Ibn ‘Adi said at the end of his biography of him, “ I do not see any problem with his hadith **, except that they have linked him with Shi’ism**.

He narrated ahadith about the merits (of the ) which were not narrated by any other trustworthy narrator. This is the worst of the accusations against him. As for the issue of truthfulness, I hope there is no problem with him, except that he had narrated munkar (repugnant) ahadith on the merits of the and in criticism of others.”[^7] There are two allegations above: ‘Abd al-Razzaq used to make mistakes when he narrated from memory.

Specifically, he also used to make mistakes in ahadith from Ma’mar. It is noteworthy that ahadith of ‘Abd…