“Ali is afraid of the sins he had committed which he asked...

“Ali is afraid of the sins he had committed which he asked Allah to forgive” – Sharah Doa al-komayl, pgs 159, 84 & 94. “The sins of Ali, which he asked Allah to forgive, are so serious that any one of them is enough to break a strong back”. “If Allah judges Ali (On the Judgement day) on the basis of his actions, he will deserve non other than the torture (of hell)”. Fi- Rehab Doa al-Komayl, pgs 94 and 275. Ali drank wine – Min Wahi al-Quran, Vol 7, pg 182.

Education and self-training were what provided Zahra with the Esmah (infallability) – Estefta’at al-Shaikh al-Tabrizi, answer No 5. There is no definite proof to the fact that Fatemah was an extraodinary woman. Ta’ ammolat Ismamiyyah Hawl al-Mar’ah Pg 9. The participation of Zahra in the Mobahilah is not proof for het greatness, as the Prophet took his family because they were dearest and the most beloved people to him, to prove that he was ready to sacrifice them for this religion.

Her participation does not prove anything else. al-Hawzah al-ilmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf /Mashedi, pg 77. I do not accept the ahadeth which say the people broke Fatimah’s rib, or beat her on her face etc – a famous recorded speech. The miscarriage of Mohsin is not an established fact, because its historic accounts are not authentic and dependable. It is also possible that the miscarriage happened due to natural causes. Prophets Sulayman’s action is not justifiable in God’s law.

●Min Wahi al-Quran, Vol 19, pg 289. Prophet Yonus neglected his duties – Min Wahi al-Quran, Vol 15, pg 284. What do Maraji say about Fadlollah ? Shaykh Mohammed-Taqi Bahjat : Fadlollah is a Wahabi project which is intended to corrode the structure of Shia’sm from the inside. Fetnat Fadlollah/al-Safi, pg 51. Shaykh Mohammed Fadil Lankarani : Surely denying Fatimah’s suffering is such as denying the self-evident history, and no-one denies it other than an obstinate hater of Ahlai-bait.

Reading Fadlollahs books and selling then are not allowed, except for those who want to respond to them. Al-Hawzah al-Elmiyyah Toden al-Enheraf / al-Mashedi, pg 378. Seyyid Mahdi Marashi : Whoever says these things and is insistent on what he says…he is “Dal” and “Modal”, (a person who is himself deviant and who also deviates others), and one cannot rely on what he believes and writes, because his books are “books of aberration” ; and it is not permitted to publish them.

It is mandatory for scholars…to stand against such persons and to warn people about them.

✦ ✦ ✦