We did not find support for the famous hadith Al-Qudsi on...

We did not find support for the famous hadith Al-Qudsi on the tongues (I was a hidden treasure, so I liked to know, so I created creation in order to know). But it appears that some of our scholars, as well as the scholars of Ahl al-Sunnah who mentioned it in their books, have accepted it and cited it, and some of them attributed it to Allah Almighty as a holy hadith: such as the investigator Al-Karaki in (his letters), he said: ((This hadith is supported by Al-Qudsi I was a treasure… etc)).

Ibn Abi Jamhour al-Ahsa’i in (Ghawali al-La’ali), and al-Majlisi in (al-Bahar). Al-Sabzwari in (Explanation of the Most Beautiful Names), said: ((One of the sins is the place of (hidden) and the places of the soul is the place of invisibility referred to by saying: I was a hidden treasure… etc)). As well as Al-Amidi of the Sunni scholars in (provisions) said: ((Peace be upon him said a story about his Lord: I was a treasure I did not know, so I created a creation to know it)).

Among those who mentioned it were also among our later scholars: Sheikh Muhammad Husayn al-Isfahani in (The End of Knowledge), Allama Al-Amini in (Al-Ghadir), Al-Miza Hussein Al-Nouri in (The Same Rahman), and others. Among the scholars of the public are Al-Alusi in his interpretation, and Haji Khalifa in (Kashf al-Dhunun). It was denied by some scholars on both sides, and several Sayyid al-Mar’ashi in (Ihqaq al-Haqq 6: 431) of the subjects.