Why did Umar include me -asws in the consultation when he...
Why did Umar include me -asws in the consultation when he and his companions had testified against the Messenger of Allah -saww (by fabricating a Hadith that Prophet-hood and Caliph will not be together)? Did he include me -asws in the consultation regarding the Caliphate or for something else?
And if you think that he made the consultation to be for something other than the Emirate, so it is not for Usman to be the Emir over us, and is it necessary for us to have a consultation for something else because he ordered us to have a consultation for something else? And if the consultation was regarding it (Caliphate), why did he include me -asws among those (the nominees)?
Did he not take me -asws out by saying that the Messenger of Allah -saww had taken out the People -asws of the Household from the Caliphate and informed that there is no share for them -asws in it (the fabricated Hadith)?\u2019 (An Extract) [20] \n After Killing of Usman, Muslims thronged to Imam Ali -asws for Bayt: \n (Ali Amir Al-Momineen -asws says in one of the Sermons) When he (Usman) was killed, and the people gathered for three days, having consultations regarding their command (ruler).