\n The authors of \u2018www.

\n The authors of \u2018www.thebohras.com\u2019 claimed, without exception, the \u2018Nuss\u2019 had to be made for each Divine successor to publically announce his legatee, which was the case from Rasool Allah -saww who publically Nominated Ali Ibn Abi Talib as his successor, and this continued as Imam Ali anncounced (Nuss) Hassan who did Nuss for Imam Hussain and so on. But Imam Jafar-e-Sadiq -asws first did Nuss for Ismail -as , which was later changed for Musa Kazim -asws .

\u00a0And then it is claimed that there was no Nuss for the 12 th Imam -asws , hence the Imamat of the 12 th Imam -asws is not proven from twelver Shia sources. See the Point [1] \u2018Nuss\u2019 in Appendix I (as copied and reproduced from Bohras official site https:\/\/www.thebohras.com\/imam.html ).

\n Ithna Asheri\u2019s (Twelver Immami) reply to [1]: \n This is true that Allah -azwj Sent His \u2018Hujjah\u2019 (Prophet -as ) first to earth so that Divine Guidance is available to all inhabitants of the earth at all times – not only to human beings but to all creatures. Allah -azwj Made it compulsory for the departing Prophet\/Imam to transfer the Divine Knowledge and make a Will to his successor prior the departing from the world.

\n This practice continued from Prophet Adam -as to -saww , as per the Divine Instructions. Each Prophet -as transferred the Knowledge and left a will for his successor, as the earth would never be without a Divine representative otherwise it would sink. The Prophets -as continued to follow the tradition of nominating their successors, sometimes announcing publicly but other times secretly .

The mode of nomination was pursuant to the Divine Commands relevant to the prevailing circumstances and in accordance with the \u2018Mashiyat\u2019 (Desire of Allah -azwj ). \n It is also quite evident that there are many years of wait for people in the appearance of a Prophet for deliverance of a Divine Message – when for ordinary people, there was neither a publicly known Prophet -as nor an Imam -asws .

\n Hence, the \u2018man-made concept\u2019 put forward in [1] \u2018Nuss\u2019 by \u2018thebohras.com\u2019 that a prophet\/Imam must announce publically his successor at all the times is inconsistent with the Sunnah. It is a \u2018man-made assumption\u2019 and without good understanding of the Book, it can be deduced that it is completely irrational and conflicting with many Verses of the Holy Quran.