I have seen the two lips of Rasool-Allah -saww upon these...
Are you crying at the victory of Allah -azwj ? By Allah -azwj ! Had you not been an aged old man having become senile and his mind has gone, I -la would have struck off your neck!’ Zayd Bin Arqam got up from in front of him -la and went to his house’.
الإرشاد ص 228، و لكن قد يقال ان زيد بن أرقم كان حينذاك أعمى: قد كف بصره بدعاء على أمير المؤمنين عليه السلام حين استشهده عن كلام رسول اللّه« من كنت مولاه فهذا على مولاه» فكتمه، كما في شرح النهج ج 1 ص 362 لابن أبي الحديد، الا انه لم يثبت، و لا نقله أرباب التراجم في ترجمته.
و لو صح لم يناف انكاره على ابن زياد بضرب القضيب على ثناياه عليه السلام، لجواز أن يكون قد أنكر على ما سمعه ممن رأى ذلك نعم قال ابن عساكر في تاريخه ج 4 ص 340 أنه كان حاضر المجلس و يؤيد ابن زياد. And if it was correct, it is not beneficial, his denial upon Ibn Ziyad -la of striking with the stick upon his -asws lips, upon him -asws be the greetings, as a permit that he had disliked it based upon what he had heard from the one who had seen that, yes.
Ibn Asakir said in his history, Vol 4 Pg 340 that he was present in the gathering and supported Ibn Ziyad -la .