ص :بحارالأنوار 342 11 باب 3- بعثته ع على قومه و قصة...

Appendix C: Objections on Nouroz-Day There has been some scepticism on the validity of Nouroz-Day’s religious grounds, cast by one of the traditions found in the shia book written by Ibn-e-Shaher Ashob ‘Manaqib-e-Alay Abi Talib’ [13] , the tradition is referred to Imam Musa-e-Kazim -asws without giving any narrators’s names and by just citing ‘it has been narrated’.

Mulla Mohammed Baqir Majalisi as well as other renowned narrators of traditions (i.e., Sheikh Al-Hurr Al-Amari) did not consider this tradition reliable and say it was, included in the book, out of Taqqia. However, we cannot not reject a tradition, based on the narrator or chain of narrators, but need to evaluate it, as per Masomeen -asws s’ prescribed criteria of the hadith authenticity ( http://hubeali.com/asool-e-deen/Chapter_17_NarratingHadith.pdf ).